All requests
ShippedPublic request — anyone can read this thread

Transcribe our videos and podcasts once, then subtitle them in every language we publish in

MRMegan RossContent Marketing Lead ·

We publish a long-form video and a podcast episode every week, and each one goes out in five languages. The recording is the easy part. What holds a release up is the captions.

What the job looks like today

  1. Someone runs the audio through a transcription tool and cleans up the transcript by hand.
  2. A translator takes the cleaned transcript and returns five documents.
  3. Someone else pastes each translation into a subtitle editor and re-times it, line by line, because the timings do not survive the round trip.

Step three is the one that costs us a day per episode. The words are already correct by then — we are paying for the clock.

What we need

  • One upload that produces the transcript and every language from it, rather than a transcript we then have to carry somewhere else.
  • Speakers separated. Half our output is two or more people in conversation and a transcript that does not say who is talking is not usable as a transcript, let alone as a subtitle.
  • Timings that carry across languages. The translation of a line belongs in the same slot the original occupied. This is the whole request.
  • SRT and VTT out, because that is what our video host and our podcast player each want.

What matters more than accuracy

A word we have to fix is a small cost. A line that sits on screen for one second or runs to three rows is one a viewer turns the captions off over — and once they are off for one episode they stay off.

So: split lines for reading speed, keep them short enough to read at a glance, and let us see the result before it goes anywhere. We would rather review five languages in an editor for twenty minutes than trust five files we never opened.

Volume

  • 4 videos + 4 podcast episodes a month, 20 to 90 minutes each
  • 5 languages: English, Turkish, German, Spanish, French
  • A back catalogue of roughly 200 episodes with no captions at all, which we would work through if the per-episode cost were close to zero
ProductivityDocumentsAutomation
Progress
  1. Filed
  2. In review
  3. Approved
  4. In progress
  5. Shipped
71 people need this too
4 commentsSorted by oldest
MR

Megan Ross, Content Marketing Lead ·
Volume, since it will decide whether this is worth building: four long-form videos and four podcast episodes a month, 20 to 90 minutes each, published in English, Turkish, German, Spanish and French.

IN

Incapon ·
The transcription half we already do. The half we will not promise untested is the subtitling — machine timings drift on overlapping speech, and a translated line is routinely half again as long as the English one, which is what turns a caption into a wall. Taking a week to measure both on your kind of material before committing to a shape.

MR

Megan Ross, Content Marketing Lead ·
Sent you three episodes to try it on, including the panel one with four people talking over each other. If it only half works there we would still take it — that is the episode we spend a whole day captioning.

IN

Incapon ·
Shipped, and the week was worth spending. Upload a video or an audio file, get a transcript with speakers separated, pick the languages, and each one comes back as SRT and VTT with the timings carried over from the original rather than re-derived per language. Lines are split to fit reading speed, not to fit the sentence. Everything lands in an editor first — nothing publishes itself.